Levees don't protect, they disconnect: A critical review of how artificial levees impact floodplain functions
Loading...
Authors
Richard L. Knox
Ellen E. Wohl
Ryan R. Morrison
Issue Date
2022-09
Type
journal-article
Language
Keywords
resilience , artificial levees , biogeochemistry , biodiversity , hazard mitigation , floodplain restoration
Alternative Title
Abstract
Despite the recognition of floodplain importance in the scientific community, floodplains are not afforded the same legal protection as river channels. In the United States alone, flood-related economic losses were much higher in the second half of the 20th century than the first half despite the expenditure of billions of dollars on flood defenses. Partially to blame are the low appraisal and understanding of human impacts to floodplain functions. Here, we explore the impacts of levees on floodplain functions and analyze case studies of floodplain restoration through levee removal. Floodplain functions include (1) fluxes of water, solutes, and particulate materials; (2) enhanced spatial heterogeneity of hydrology and biogeochemistry; (3) enhanced habitat abundance and diversity; (4) enhanced biomass and biodiversity; and (5) hazard mitigation. Case studies of floodplain restoration involving artificial levee adjustment are heavily concentrated in North America, Europe, and Japan, and those case studies assess floodplain functions within 30 years of restoration. In the United States, restoration through levee removal comprises less than 1% of artificial levee length and 1–2% of disconnected floodplains. In Europe, restoration effectiveness was severely limited by upstream flow regulation. Most case studies were impacted by stressors outside the study site and took place in lowland alluvial rivers. Reconfiguration was successful at achieving limited aims while reconnection set floodplains on a trajectory to more fully restore floodplain functions. Case studies illustrated the tension between restoration scale and study resolution in time and space as well as the role of site-specific characteristics in determining restoration outcomes. Numerous knowledge gaps surrounding the integrative relationships between floodplain functions must be addressed in future studies. The ubiquity of flow regulation demands that future floodplain restoration occur in a whole-of-basin manner. Monitoring of restoration must take place for longer periods of time and include multiple functions.
Description
Citation
Knox, Richard L., Ellen E. Wohl, and Ryan R. Morrison. "Levees don't protect, they disconnect: A critical review of how artificial levees impact floodplain functions." Science of the Total Environment 837 (2022): 155773.
Publisher
Elsevier BV
License
Journal
Volume
Issue
PubMed ID
ISSN
0048-9697